I was raised Catholic by two people who, I think it's fair to say, cared more about the tradition of raising your children Catholic than the actual, you know, God part of the whole equation. I know that when I was tiny, we went to church fairly regularly. My younger-by-two-years sister and I have memories of mass on Sundays and frilly new dresses to wear at Easter.
(She remembers because she loved the dresses. I remember because even by six, I could think of no greater torment than scratchy white tights and patent leather shoes.)
By the time my brother came along, we were what my mother affectionately referred to as "C & E Catholics", which is to say that we got our asses to church on the two big holidays and hoped that the buzz would carry us through the rest of the year. The fact that we children attended Catholic elementary school gave us an extra once-monthly dose of church at a minimum, not to mention bi-weekly Religion classes and general integration of Christian teachings into other subjects.
I definitely started out a believer. But as time passed and I grew older, the scientist in me grew skeptical. I understood the arguments but just couldn't wrap my head around the whole Intelligent Design business. And that led to doubting the existence of any God at all. And so when I was given the option of going to either public or Separate high school, I went with public.
(Also because the Catholic high school was in another town and required a half hour bus ride, while the public school was within walking distance. Staying in town seemed like an incredibly great idea and I gave my parents the hard-sell. "Think of how much more sleep I'd get! Not to mention the fact that I'd be able to take my time getting ready. The mornings would be so totally WASTED if I had to be out of the house at a set-in-stone time to catch a bus, rather than needing to leave somewhere in that vague window that would make it possible to quickly stop at my locker before class. This way I can use my time before school to recheck my homework or maybe take up jogging or something! My mornings will be so much better spent!")
("So much better spent" actually turned out to be more along the lines of sleeping in until I had exactly as much time as I needed to get ready less ten minutes, thereby insuring that I would be running out the door in a panic EVERY DAMN DAY. But I digress.)
Where was I? Oh right, Catholicism. So, I drifted away from the church and its teachings. I settled into a pretty comfortable outlook that, while it (and really all organized religion) wasn't something that I subscribed to, if you're a believer, I'm simply happy that you're happy.
Fast forward seven or eight years and I'm getting married to a guy who does believe in God and all the stuff that goes with it. (Well... not all. We both share the same opinion of the church's intolerance of homosexuality and some of the other hot-button issues.) He's Greek Orthodox, which even the Catholics will tell you is very nearly the same thing, and went to Catholic high school.
We talked about the whole religion/kids thing early on and came to a consensus. We'd explain to any future children what we each believe, and that other people may believe differently, and just sort of let the kids mature into their own opinions. I also agreed that since religion isn't really important to me but it is to him, the kids could be given the sacraments (baptism, communion, confirmation, etc). In fact, I'm all for it because the family traditions surrounding those events are great memories for me. Whether or not they'd go to Catholic school would depend on the quality of the school in question, not on whether or not religion was taught there.
And now... we're in the thick of it. Eli remains, as of yet, unbaptized. We're working out the details but the major roadblock seems to be deciding which church. There's a Catholic church nearby and that would make things easy as far as showing our faces often enough. Plus, we could have the actual ceremony at the church in my parents' town, since we're going to have a party at their house afterward. But the Catholic church has shown itself to be a lot fonder of throwing hurdles in our way, one of which being the question of whether we should wait until we've had our marriage blessed (which would take six to eight months of meetings and then a donation and oh, can't you just put the standing of your first-born's soul on the back burner while you complete our marriage preparedness course? Also, please come every week and don't forget your envelopes full of money for the offering because we'd hate to think you weren't coming to church often enough). However, the Orthodox church is so far away that it'd be impossible for us to attend nearly as regularly... but from what we've heard, they'd be a lot more open to accepting a single envelope o' money to perform the deed. We can continue to take Eli to the Catholic church and send him to Catholic school either way.
And then there's the question of Godparents. You have to be a member of the Catholic church in good standing to qualify. Most of my family has lapsed and wouldn't be eligible, so our obvious choices (my sister, for example) are out. None of our friends are Catholic, so no help there. If we go with Orthodox, there are more options. Again, the Orthodox church seems like they'd be willing to be a
little... looser on their definition of "practicing", not requiring
letters from the Godparents' parishes and such. Pete's aunt and cousins (with whom he's very close) are all possibilities. It's probably going to come down to just how strict the Orthodox church is when it comes to attendance because most of Peter's family lives near us, which is to say an hour or more from the nearest church. So they don't go very often. His cousins do go to the Catholic high school, though.
Anyway, I wish I had some sort of revelation that would tie this post together but I don't. In fact, the whole issue has been up in the air for MONTHS now, and it's driving me seven different kinds of crazy, and frankly, if it's driving me crazy I don't see why all of you should get a witty narrative with a satisfying conclusion.
(Did I mention that the crazy is making me kind of bitchy? No? Well, you'll just have to use your imaginations to picture it then.)